Page 1 of 1

BM Study - Candlestick OHCL across 4 platforms.

Posted: Mon Sep 21, 2020 9:54 pm
by godog
So did a study today on $PIC 10:12 1 minute chart across four different charting platforms.

Barring the same between Sterling and CS, each produced a different looking candle, BM being the most extreme.  Not sure what to make of this but is concerning if I am looking for the first 1 minute candle to make a new high as a entry.  BM would have singled an entry whereas all the others would have me waiting for two more candles to pass.  All platforms have the highest level of Level 2 Data available.

Thoughts?


[img][/img]

Re: Candlestick OHCL across 4 platforms.

Posted: Tue Sep 22, 2020 7:18 am
by Svyatoslav
Hi. As you probably have noticed, image didn't attach correctly. But never mind, I can extract it. Assuming you wanted to attach this:
index.png
index.png (4.25 KiB) Viewed 415 times
It is not enough for us to investigate. I at least need a screenshot from Bookmap with trade circles turned on. Since candles are just a very basic aggregation of trades, we should be able to see the individual trades it was made from. Please switch dots to "total volume" and clustering to "none" so we can inspect raw data.